Positioning Is a Knife Fight You're Pretending Isn't Happening

Soft, vague positioning is how a product dies politely. A new PM's guide to picking a fight on purpose, and surviving it.

The first real product strategy meeting you attend as a new PM will include, somewhere in the middle, a slide that says something like "the all-in-one platform for modern teams." Everyone will nod. That sentence, which sounds helpful, is doing approximately nothing. It is a positioning statement that refuses to pick a fight.

Positioning is not a marketing activity. It is a strategic act of aggression. You are telling a specific audience that a specific alternative they are currently using is the wrong answer for them, and that you are the right one. If your positioning doesn't do that, it isn't doing anything. It is just taking up space on the homepage.

The three flinches that produce mushy positioning

New PMs — and, honestly, lots of senior ones — avoid sharp positioning for three very human reasons.

1. "We don't want to alienate the other users." Translation: we want to keep the door open for a second, larger market we haven't actually won yet. This is the single most common way products dilute themselves into nothing.
2. "Sales will hate it if we get this specific." Sales will, briefly, before noticing they close faster because the buyer actually recognises themselves.
3. "The CEO likes the current wording." The CEO also likes their first draft of every document they've ever written. This is not a strategic input.

The cost of mushy positioning is invisible, which is why it's so easy to live with. You just slowly fail to be picked. Nobody writes you an angry email to tell you they chose a competitor. They just chose.

What sharp positioning does that soft positioning doesn't

Notice the pattern. The sharp version names a specific person doing a specific thing with a specific feeling about a specific alternative. The soft version names a market segment and a vibe. You cannot build a product to the soft version, because there is no user in it.

A working frame: four components, no fluff

Ignore the 40-slide positioning workshop. For a new PM, here is the working kit.

1. The target. Who specifically. "Operations leaders at Series B-to-D companies" is too loose. "Operations leaders who just inherited three acquired teams and a broken tool stack" is a target.
2. The alternatives. What they use today, including spreadsheets, meetings, nothing, and the competitor they half-pretend not to evaluate. You must name at least three or you haven't looked.
3. The unique value. The specific thing you do that their current alternative can't, said in one sentence, without the word leverage.
4. The cost of the alternative. What happens to the target if they stay on what they have. If nothing bad happens, your product isn't a purchase, it's a hobby.

Run this once, seriously, with two colleagues and a whiteboard. You will produce something that sounds scarier than your current homepage. That is the correct reaction. If it doesn't scare anyone slightly, you haven't finished.

Positioning is a decision a new PM can actually influence

Here is the useful bit: you do not need to be the VP of Product to move the needle on positioning. You can start with one surface — an onboarding empty state, an in-product microcopy, a comparison page, a feature name — and make that one thing positioned sharply.

You will find, within a quarter, that the sharper microcopy converts better than the bland version. You will bring those numbers into a room. Someone more senior than you will ask "what would we need to change on the homepage to match?" That is how positioning gets upgraded in big orgs — not by a single dramatic rebrand, but by a new PM being quietly right about their one surface, three quarters in a row.

If your positioning could be pasted onto three of your competitors' sites without anyone noticing, it is not positioning. It is background noise.

The one-sentence test

Write your positioning on an index card. Cross out every word that a competitor could also say. What remains is your actual positioning. If three words remain, you have work to do. If one word remains, it is probably the word we, and you have more work to do.

A product that is for everyone is, in practice, for no-one who is going to remember it on a Tuesday. Strategy is choice. Positioning is the public face of that choice. Refusing to make it is the thing, not building it.

← Back to Product Strategy